D.S. & Durga Big Sur After Rain: What a 3.7-Star Rating and a WOW Score of 9 Have in Common
Made the cut
Fifty-seven Amazon ratings. 3.7 stars. That number stopped us during research.
Then we pulled the distribution: 55% five-star, 18% one-star. Both camps describe the same candle. One reviewer says it smells exactly like Big Sur. Another finds it cloying. They are both right. The scent is that specific.
We scored D.S. & Durga Big Sur After Rain an 8.32 overall. The highest dimension was WOW at 9, which measures uniqueness and discovery factor. A Brooklyn fragrance house capturing California coastal landscapes in wax, carried by Nordstrom and Liberty London.
Armchair Travel in a Candle
David Moltz, the voice of the Brooklyn brand, puts it this way: “Perfume is armchair travel. You can put a whole world into a package with stories, so they can travel through this world.”
The Big Sur After Rain candle puts that idea into wax.
The scent profile is coastal rain and eucalyptus shoot on top, magnolia and Pacific spray in the heart, eucalyptus leaf and wet wood at the base. That is not a fragrance category. That is coordinates on a map.
Business of Fashion has covered the Brooklyn brand’s global expansion with Manzanita Capital.
What the Scores Reveal
GLOW scored 8. The vessel is minimalist glass with wax in muted earth tones. Understated Brooklyn indie aesthetic with clean product photography against natural textures. It disappears into the room until someone asks about the scent.
WOW scored 9. It requires depth of story you cannot easily find elsewhere. A Brooklyn perfume house that calls perfume armchair travel and a scent of coastal rain and eucalyptus, all in a 7oz candle at $70.
Nordstrom, Liberty London, and Space NK stock it.
MOMENT scored 8. First light fills the room with coastal eucalyptus and wet wood. The scent does not register as a candle. It registers as a place.
One Amazon reviewer burns it in the guest bathroom every time people come over and says everyone loves it. The small vessel size at $70 makes the price a conversation point, which for the right recipient is part of the gift.
TRUST scored 7.8. The 3.7-star Amazon rating from 57 ratings gave us pause. Then we noticed the distribution. Stocked at Nordstrom, Liberty London, Space NK.
The polarization is not noise. It is signal. One reviewer writes ‘Best candle we buy’; another calls the scent cloying. That honesty is built into the product.
The $70 Question
At $70 for 7oz, the price is part of the conversation. One reviewer’s verdict: ‘Perfect smell, imperfect price.’
The negative Amazon reviews tell you exactly who this candle is not for. That clarity is valuable.
The candle is 7oz, a scent built on coastal rain, eucalyptus and wet wood.
Who We Matched It To
Our gift intelligence flagged this candle for daughters shopping for moms who already have a candle on the mantel but nothing beyond Jo Malone or Diptyque. The gift signal shifts from “it smells lovely” to something more specific.
Someone who shops at Liberty London and notices which candle a restaurant burns. Someone who has an opinion about Diptyque or wants to. Someone who judges atmosphere deliberately.
It also matched strongly for a close friend’s birthday, particularly the friend who introduced you to niche fragrance and already knows Le Labo and Aesop. D.S. & Durga is the Brooklyn perfume house she might not have discovered yet.
For host gifts, the eucalyptus layers with food rather than competing, and the candle becomes a recurring part of future dinner parties rather than a single-evening gesture.
Skip if the recipient prefers vanilla, lavender, or identifiably sweet candle scents. Skip if $70 feels excessive for 7oz. This candle is for adventurous taste, not consensus approval.
Final Scoring
D.S. & Durga Big Sur After Rain scored 8.32 overall. GLOW at 8, WOW at 9, MOMENT at 8, TRUST at 7.8.
The 3.7-star Amazon rating did not lower our confidence. It confirmed what the score already measured: this is a candle specific enough to divide a room, from a Brooklyn perfume house that calls perfume armchair travel.