Your product on SleekNova? 99% don't make it. Try anyway →

Forty-One Press Features, Ten Reviews, and Five Hundredths of a Point

Eight of the ten reviews come from people who rented them. One wore them to a wedding and wrote that she did not want to send them back.

Did not pass

Jennifer Sarkilahti trained as a painter. She holds a Master of Fine Arts from George Mason University. She moved to New York, worked on Christo and Jeanne-Claude’s The Gates installation in Central Park during the freezing winter of 2005, and one afternoon walked past a bead shop in midtown Manhattan.

She bought supplies. Started making things at her kitchen table. Taught herself lost-wax casting. Named the brand Odette, after something half-remembered from Swan Lake, because she was still painting under her own name.

That was 2006.

Twenty years later, Odette New York operates from a converted barn from the 1800s in the Hudson Valley. Michelle Obama wore the Helene Hoops on the Ellen show. The press page lists 41 features across Vogue (including the September 2018 Beyoncé issue), Harper’s Bazaar, Architectural Digest, Elle, Porter, and Marie Claire.

Nordstrom currently carries 23 Odette products. J.Crew listed the exact earrings we evaluated. They sold out.

And across the entire internet, ten people have reviewed the Lalo Earrings.

What We Found

The Lalo Earrings are sculptural brass drops, hand-carved from wax and cast in recycled metal by family-run foundries in New York City. They retail for $165 on the brand’s own site. Sterling silver posts. 1.5 inches long.

The designer herself wears them. In an interview with Multifaceted Magazine, Sarkilahti listed the Lalo alongside the Mezzaluna as her current personal rotation.

We found eight product-specific reviews on Rent the Runway, where reviewers must have physically received the product before reviewing. The consensus was clear: lightweight, comfortable, sculptural presence without the heft. One reviewer wore them to a wedding and a black-tie event and wrote that she didn’t want to return them. Another called them good for presentations and big meetings. A third simply said: might keep them.

On J.Crew, two verified buyers rated them 5.0 stars. One noted the craftsmanship. The other mentioned the comfort. Both were concise. Both were specific. Both sounded like people who had actually worn the earrings, because they had.

Across those two platforms, the combined rating sits at approximately 4.5 stars from 10 reviews. All positive. No complaints about quality, fit, or finish.

The Paradox

Odette New York has the profile of a brand whose products should have hundreds of reviews. Nordstrom distribution. J.Crew partnership. 68 independent stockists across the United States, plus retailers in Tokyo, Mexico, and Zurich. Professional wholesale representation through Franklin Showroom.

Celebrity styling credits that span Michelle Obama, Taylor Swift, Gisele Bündchen, Issa Rae, Cynthia Erivo, and Tracee Ellis Ross.

But independent jewelry brands that sell through their own Squarespace site and wholesale to boutiques rarely accumulate the kind of review density that mass-market platforms generate. There is no native review widget on odetteny.com. The brand’s Instagram has 16,900 followers, not 169,000. Each piece is hand-carved, cast in small batches, sold through shops where the transaction happens in person, not online.

The review economy rewards volume. It does not reward the kind of slow, studio-based practice that defines Odette.

Where It Landed

GLOW (visual appeal): 9 out of 10. The sculptural organic form, the kinetic movement, the hand-textured brass surface that catches light from different angles. This is what happens when a trained painter approaches metal as a material.

WOW (discovery factor): 8 out of 10. Odette New York has two decades of Vogue features and a First Lady wearing the hoops. We still count it a discovery, and that gap between editorial recognition and wider notice is what we score.

MOMENT (gift scene): 8 out of 10. The earrings are light enough to wear daily but sculptural enough to prompt a question. Reviewers on Rent the Runway used the word “elevate” without prompting.

TRUST: 6.0 out of 10. Ten verified product reviews across two credible platforms. Extraordinary brand-level validation, but our confidence scoring system weights product-specific evidence heavily, as it should. The brand pedigree is undeniable. The product review base is thin.

Final score: 7.95. Our threshold is 8.0.

The gap is five hundredths of a point.

What Would Change

More verified product reviews across additional platforms would shift the confidence score. That is the singular factor separating the Lalo Earrings from the threshold. The visual impact, the discovery potential, the gift-giving moment all cleared their respective bars. The math failed on review density alone.

We will revisit this product if the review landscape changes.


SCS Global certified recycled metals. Sterling silver posts. Hand-carved in a Hudson Valley barn by a painter who became a jeweler by accident.

Sometimes the math catches up last.

The record

7.95 / 10

Our bar 8.0 Short by 0.05

Fell short on Score
Experiment ID LN-2026-250