Why Material Quality Determines Whether Your Gift Gets Kept or Forgotten
Does engraving void a warranty?
Engraving can cost warranty cover if the maker's terms say so: TAG Heuer's connected-watch warranty does not cover engraving. What a company can't do, the FTC says, is void your warranty solely because someone not associated with it did repairs or other services, though it may refuse damage that work caused. Read the terms, and ask if the maker engraves.
Does engraving void a warranty under US warranty law?
The warranty line you may have in mind says the warranty is void if anyone but the maker's authorized dealer works on the product. The US federal rule on warranties, 16 CFR 700.10, names that kind of line, a warranty "void if service is performed by anyone other than an authorized" dealer, and prohibits it where the warranty does not cover that service. It also bars a warranty that stays valid only while you use the maker's authorized repair service or parts for upkeep outside the warranty, unless the maker provides them free, and it says a maker "cannot, as a matter of law, avoid liability" for a defect unrelated to someone else's work.
Under the Magnuson-Moss Warranty Act, the FTC's consumer alert says in plainer words, a company can't void your warranty or deny coverage solely because you got "repairs done or other services from someone not associated with the company", unless it provides them free.
Warranties that said they would be void if anyone else supplied the parts or repairs led to FTC settlements in 2022 with Harley-Davidson, the maker of Weber grills and the maker of Westinghouse generators. Neither the rule nor the alert mentions engraving.
The half a maker's terms decide
The protection stops at damage the other work caused, and past that line each maker's warranty speaks for itself. The same rule does not stop a maker from "expressly excluding liability for defects or damage caused by" work it did not authorize, and the alert says companies "may, however, refuse warranty coverage for defects or damage caused by using third-party parts or third-party services." What counts as that damage is left for the maker to write down, and TAG Heuer's connected-watch warranty uses that room. Its list of what it does not cover includes software and hardware modifications, unauthorized repairs and "Engraving".
On a watch, the case back can already carry an engraving of its own: at TAG Heuer, the serial number. TAG Heuer's international warranty says the serial number "must remain clearly legible", and that no part of the original case back or the serial number may be "missing, modified, falsified, altered, replaced, erased, defaced or rendered illegible", or the warranty is "null and void". TAG Heuer's own page on it does not say whether a name added beside the serial counts, so ask the maker before the case back goes to an engraver.
So the word to look for in your own maker's terms may not be engraving at all. The terms for the Mason Pearson hairbrush we list describe companies that personalise its brushes by painting names on them, say the maker is not affiliated with them, and then add:
Painting or otherwise decorating the hairbrush will void any warranty we may provide.
Whichever word your maker uses, whether engraving, decorating, modified, altered or defaced, that line is the one to find before you order.
Who holds the tool, and what goes in the box
Against a rule that lets a maker refuse damage someone else's work caused, the one choice still yours is who holds the tool. Where the maker does the personalizing, the warranty can stay. Frank Clegg stamps initials into its leather travel kit before the kit ships, and a monogrammed kit stays covered by its lifetime warranty. Mr Jones Watches offers its Colour Venn with a blank caseback and personalized engraving for $13 extra, beside a five-year warranty; our page on that watch does not say how one bears on the other, so ask before you order.
Two things travel with the gift. At Frank Clegg, a monogrammed kit can't be sent back, so the name ends any return before it is unwrapped. And a watch's warranty can depend on paper: TAG Heuer's international warranty card "must be presented at the time of repair", so it belongs in the box with the watch. After that, the warranty is the recipient's to use, and the piece's own material is what decides whether it is kept or forgotten.
Read next
Why Material Quality Determines Whether Your Gift Gets Kept or Forgotten
What this rests on
25 claims, from 16 CFR 700.10, Prohibited tying 2015, FTC Consumer Alert, July 7, 2022 2022, TAG Heuer, connected watch warranty policy (FAQ), TAG Heuer, international warranty conditions (FAQ), Mason Pearson, Terms and Conditions, Frank Clegg Small Travel Kit and Mr Jones Watches Colour Venn. Each has its own address.
Grouped under the record each claim came from.
16 CFR 700.10, Prohibited tying 2015
“This warranty is void if service is performed by anyone other than an authorized `ABC' dealer and all replacement parts must be genuine `ABC' parts,” and the like, are prohibited where the service or parts are not covered by the warranty.
citea warrantor cannot, as a matter of law, avoid liability under a written warranty where a defect is unrelated to the use by a consumer of “unauthorized” articles or service.
citeThis does not preclude a warrantor from expressly excluding liability for defects or damage caused by “unauthorized” articles or service; nor does it preclude the warrantor from denying liability where the warrantor can demonstrate that the defect or damage was so caused.
citeprohibits tying arrangements that condition coverage under a written warranty on the consumer's use of an article or service identified by brand, trade, or corporate name unless that article or service is provided without charge to the consumer.
citeNo warrantor may condition the continued validity of a warranty on the use of only authorized repair service and/or authorized replacement parts for non-warranty service and maintenance
citeFTC Consumer Alert, July 7, 2022 2022
Among other things, the Warranty Act says that companies can’t void your warranty or deny warranty coverage solely because you use a part made by another company or because you get repairs done or other services from someone not associated with the company, unless the company provides the part or service for free under the warranty.
citeCompanies may, however, refuse warranty coverage for defects or damage caused by using third-party parts or third-party services.
citeThe FTC’s lawsuits allege that the companies violated the Magnuson-Moss Warranty Act.
citeAccording to the FTC, all three companies broke the law by telling customers that their warranties would be void if the customers got parts or repairs from anyone except the companies or their authorized dealers.
citeHarley-Davidson motorcycles, MWE Investments
citewhich makes Westinghouse-brand outdoor power generators
citemaker of Weber grills.
citeTAG Heuer, international warranty conditions (FAQ)
No part of the original case back or the serial number may be missing, modified, falsified, altered, replaced, erased, defaced or rendered illegible.
citeFailure to meet any of the above conditions will render the TAG Heuer International Warranty null and void.
citeThe serial number engraved on the case back must remain clearly legible.
citeThe international warranty card included with your purchase must be presented at the time of repair.
citeMason Pearson, Terms and Conditions
Painting or otherwise decorating the hairbrush will void any warranty we may provide.
citeWe are aware that some companies personalise our hairbrushes by painting names and other designs on the hairbrushes.
citeWe are not affiliated with these companies, have no control over them and are not responsible for their work.
citeInitials are stamped into the leather before the kit ships. Monogrammed items cannot be returned but remain covered by the lifetime warranty.
cite