Your product on SleekNova? 99% don't make it. Try anyway →

Why We Rejected 112 ‘Top-Rated’ Gifts (And What That Teaches You)

Is a Kickstarter product a good gift?

The short answer

A Kickstarter product can be a good gift once it has shipped and its buyers rate it well. Backing a live campaign is a bet on timing: Kickstarter calls the delivery date a goal, not a guarantee. And a big backer count suggests the idea looked credible and useful, not that the person who gets it will love it.

What the crowd vouches for

Start with the backer count on the campaign page, because it does tell you something real about the product — just not everything a good gift needs. Campaigns that funded came out ahead on credibility, feasibility, reliability and usefulness when 120 business analysts scored 20 high-tech Kickstarter campaigns picked in 2023 for a 2026 study, without being told which ones had funded. The pattern held for how many backers each one drew, not only for whether it funded.

What the count doesn't carry is newness. In those same ratings, funded and unfunded campaigns came out level on novelty, uniqueness and how far their audience reached, and the researchers note that newness is hard to judge from short campaign descriptions. We met that gap with the Mezmoglobe: its campaign drew 5,145 backers and its 182 reviews held not one negative, and we still didn't recommend it as a gift, because for our readers it was a product many had already come across — not a find.

Backing a live campaign as a present

Then there is the delivery date beside the reward. When you pledge, Kickstarter's own help pages say, you are "not purchasing, or pre-ordering, an existing item—you are helping to create something new." Every campaign has to set an estimated delivery date, and the platform says that date is the creator's goal for when shipping starts — and no promise of when your reward arrives. Delays, Kickstarter says, "may be just a few weeks, but it is not uncommon for delays to go over six months."

On time, by two counts

How often the date holds turns on who did the counting. Only 24.9% of funded Design and Technology projects — the kinds that usually ship a physical product — delivered on time, across the 381 from 2009 to July 2012 that promised a delivery date and whose outcome a 2014 study could trace. Another 33% had not delivered at all when they were counted, and the 247 that had delivered arrived 1.28 months late on average.

The backers' own answers put it higher: they agreed their reward came on time for 65% of projects and disagreed for 17%. That survey's answers came from 47,188 backers of 30,323 projects from 2009 to May 2015, and Kickstarter itself ran it, with questions written jointly with the researcher who analysed the answers. The two numbers measure different things: one checked promised dates on design and technology projects, the other asked backers across categories. Which leaves the obvious comfort: surely a campaign that has blown far past its goal is the surest bet.

In those 2009 to 2012 projects, it ran the other way. The bigger the project, the longer its delays ran, and even at the same size, the further a project overshot its goal, the later it tended to deliver:

Projects that are funded at 10× their goal are half as likely to deliver at a given time, compared to projects funded at their goal.

The number of backers made no difference to the delay at all, and neither did the type of project. Late, though, is not the worst case.

If it never comes

Around 9% of funded Kickstarter projects failed, likely somewhere between 5% and 14%, by their backers' own answers in the survey Kickstarter ran — failed meaning they never expect the reward, or got one that wasn't what was promised. When a project failed, the money rarely came back: only around 13% of backers whose project failed reported getting a refund or other compensation, and in the researcher's words, failure "seems to generally leave backers in the dark, without a refund or detailed explanation from creators." Once the money has paid for production, materials, postage or someone's time, a refund may not be possible — Kickstarter's own help pages say as much.

Reading a live campaign

Telling which live campaigns will deliver is hard: once a campaign has reached its goal, few signs a backer can see predict failure, by that same survey.

  • Size says a little — smaller projects failed most often, mid-size ones least, and the largest somewhat more than the middle.
  • Film, technology and food campaigns failed more often, music campaigns much less, which is worth knowing when the present is a gadget.
  • Campaigns that showed the creator's effort, with a video or updates posted before the deadline, failed less, but the effect was small.

When is a Kickstarter product a good gift?

Once it has shipped, there is something a live campaign can't give you: what its buyers thought. Across 211 crowdfunded products rated on Amazon in a 2026 study, the more backers a product had, the more widely it was taken up — and the lower its average star rating, wherever it had been slow to reach the market; where it arrived quickly, the crowd's size made no significant difference. Bigger crowds also went with higher expectations, and with lower quality in buyers' own reviews. On that same yardstick, one maker's two Kickstarter objects came out differently. FLYTE's Light Edison, a light bulb that floats, drew 2,000 backers in 2015 and has sold on Amazon since December 2016, where its 43 reviews average 3.7 stars; the lower-rated ones are about getting it to float steadily and about how long it lasts. We turned it down. The Buda Ball, from the same maker, drew 1,815 backers and sits at 4.4 stars from 54 Amazon ratings, and it passed our check. The Buda Ball's outcome was the common one: 17 of the 21 objects whose notes say they began as a crowdfunding campaign passed, and 4 did not, out of the 612 our lab had ruled on as of November 13, 2026; the other 591 notes don't say how their objects were funded.

Those ratings sit on Amazon's listings. If the one you have in mind is sold only from its maker's website, hold it to the checks 112 celebrated gifts did not pass before you back it.

Read next

Why We Rejected 112 ‘Top-Rated’ Gifts (And What That Teaches You)

What this rests on

57 claims, from van Teunenbroek et al., Journal of Business Venturing Insights 2026, SleekNova Lab: Mezmoglobe 2026, Kickstarter Help Center 2026, Mollick, Journal of Business Venturing 2014, Mollick, Delivery Rates on Kickstarter (Wharton) 2015, Zhang, Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science 2026, SleekNova Lab: FLYTE Light Edison 2026 and Flyte Buda Ball. Each has its own address.

Grouped under the record each claim came from.

van Teunenbroek et al., Journal of Business Venturing Insights 2026

Crowdfunding success signals consumer appeal, not innovation.

cite

Despite being unaware of their funding status, the experts consistently rated successful projects higher on credibility, feasibility, reliability, and usefulness.

cite

Across these models (see Table 10), the pattern closely replicated Table 3: Credibility, Reliability, Feasibility, Quality, Usefulness, and Grade consistently predicted higher funding performance, whereas Novelty and Uniqueness remained non-significant.

cite

To assess whether the results depended on the binary success threshold, we conducted additional analyses using three continuous crowdfunding outcomes (percentage funded, number of donors, and average donation amount).

cite

Twenty high-tech gadget projects from Kickstarter were manually selected between May and September 2023 (see the supplementary materials for the specific projects2).

cite

A sample of 120 business analysts assessed 20 high-tech Kickstarter projects, half of which were successful and half of which were unsuccessful, resulting in 240 expert evaluations.

cite

No significant differences were found among Novelty, Uniqueness, or Audience reach.

cite

In interpreting the non-significant differences in novelty and uniqueness, it is important to note that perceived innovation is difficult to assess (Cattani et al., 2017), especially from short campaign descriptions.

cite

SleekNova Lab: Mezmoglobe 2026

Its designer has run seven Kickstarter campaigns for objects like it. By the time we scored this one, surprise was what was missing.

cite

£232,331 from 5,145 backers

cite

That is 182 reviews with zero negatives.

cite

For the design-aware audience SleekNova serves, this is a product many have already encountered.

cite

It is not a discovery.

cite

Kickstarter Help Center 2026

Kickstarter is not a store and creators are responsible for the final delivery of their rewards, including deciding what their refund policy will be.

cite

when you decide to pledge towards a project on Kickstarter you are not purchasing, or pre-ordering, an existing item—you are helping to create something new

cite

This date is intended as a goal for when the creator hopes to start shipping rewards, and should not be treated as a guarantee of when backers can expect to start receiving rewards.

cite

This may be just a few weeks, but it is not uncommon for delays to go over six months.

cite

When a creator is building their project on Kickstarter, they are required to set an estimated delivery date.

cite

If the funds have already been used to pay for production, materials, postage, or a person’s time, then a refund may not be possible.

cite

Mollick, Journal of Business Venturing 2014

Finally, I find that the vast majority of founders seem to fulfill their obligations to funders, but that over 75% deliver products later than expected, with the degree of delay predicted by the level and amount of funding a project receives.

cite

I used the universe of projects on Kickstarter from its inception in 2009 to July, 2012.

cite

Design and Technology projects are treated somewhat differently by Kickstarter, since they usually deliver concrete products as rewards.

cite

To analyze the outcomes of crowdfunding efforts, I used the 471 successful Kickstarter projects in the categories of Design and Technology that had promised delivery dates for rewards to funders before July, 2012.

cite

Out of the 471 projects, 381 had clearly identifiable outcomes.

cite

Of the 247 projects that delivered goods, the mean delay was 1.28 months (sd = 1.56). Of the 126 projects that were delayed, the mean delay to date was 2.4 months (sd = 1.97).

cite

Only 24.9% of projects delivered on time, and 33% had yet to deliver.

cite

As can also be seen in Fig. 3, larger projects suffer much longer delays than smaller projects.

cite

even controlling for project size, the degree to which projects are overfunded also predicts delays.

cite

Projects that are funded at 10× their goal are half as likely to deliver at a given time, compared to projects funded at their goal.

cite

I found no effect from the type of project (graphic design versus technology, for example) or the number of backers.

cite

Mollick, Delivery Rates on Kickstarter (Wharton) 2015

Overall, in terms of dollars, 8.2% of all dollars pledged to successfully funded projects goes to those that ultimately fail to deliver promised rewards.

cite

For the backer data, Kickstarter conducted the survey using questions jointly developed with me, but shared all relevant non-private data.

cite

In total 456,751 backers were surveyed, representing 65,326 projects. All projects from 2009 through May, 2015 that raised over $1,000 were included in the sample, as well as half the projects that raised less than $1,000 but over $250, and a quarter of projects raising less than $250.

cite

A total of 47,188 backers (10.3%) responded. In total, there is at least one response for 30,323 projects, (46.4% of all projects), with 1.56 backer responses per project on average.

cite

For this paper, I consider failures to be those projects where backers answer that they “never expect to get the promised reward” (5.2% of all responses) or that they “received the reward but it was not what was promised” (2% of all responses).

cite

Combining all of these results, the overall failure rate for Kickstarter projects at the project level is around 9%, and likely in a range between 5% and 14%.

cite

Failure seems to generally leave backers in the dark, without a refund or detailed explanation from creators.

cite

For backers that report that a project has failed, around 13% report receiving a refund or other compensation, and around 17% agree or strongly agree that they understood why the project failed.

cite

Failure rates are highest for smaller projects, lowest for mid-size projects, and somewhat elevated for the largest projects.

cite

Film, technology, and food projects have greater chances of failure, while music projects are much less likely to fail.

cite

Other than category differences, there were few factors apparent to backers during the campaign that predicted failure, though projects that showed signs of creator effort, by having videos or by posting updates before the fundraising deadline, were less likely to fail.

cite

These had relatively small effects, however.

cite

Overall, for backers considering funding a project, there are currently few signs about which project will fail, assuming it has reached its goal.

cite

Backers agreed or strongly agreed with the statement that “the reward was delivered on time” for 65% of projects (i.e. the average answers from backers for a project ranged from 4-5 on a 5 point scale); they disagreed or strongly disagreed with the statement for 17% of projects (1-2 on the scale); and for the remainder neither agreed nor disagreed that delivery was on time

cite

Zhang, Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science 2026

Moreover, time to market worsens the negative relationship between crowd size and customer satisfaction.

cite

Using longitudinal data on 211 crowdfunding projects, we find that crowd size (i.e., the number of backers) functions as a double-edged sword: It is positively related to product adoption but negatively related to customer satisfaction.

cite

Customer satisfaction was measured by the average rating (out of 5 stars) given on amazon.com.

cite

When time to market was high, crowd size was negatively related to customer satisfaction (Time 1: b=−0.24, t=−3.92, p <.01; Time 2: b=−0.23, t=−4.23, p <.01). When time to market was low, the effect was not significant (Time 1: t=−0.47, p =.65; Time 2: t=−0.55, p =.58).

cite

In brief, we analyzed information on each product's Amazon webpage and conducted an experiment to confirm the positive crowd-expectation association, and we adopted product reviews written by customers to validate the negative crowd-quality association.

cite

SleekNova Lab: FLYTE Light Edison 2026

Final SleekNova score: 7.68. Our threshold is 8.0.

cite

That is how much money 2,000 people gave Simon Morris on Kickstarter in 2015 to watch a light bulb float.

cite

The FLYTE Light Edison has been available on Amazon since December 2016, sold directly by FLYTE through Amazon Fulfillment.

cite

43 reviews with an average rating of 3.7 out of 5 stars

cite

The lower-rated reviews raised concerns about the learning curve for achieving stable levitation and about long-term durability.

cite

The Buda Ball at $159 has a stronger review base and a higher rating than the Light Edison at $329. Both come from Simon Morris. One passed. One did not.

cite

Flyte Buda Ball

Kickstarter campaign raised $226,495 from 1,815 backers

cite

4.4 out of 5 stars, 54 ratings on Amazon product listing

cite