Your product on SleekNova? 99% don't make it. Try anyway →

Baby & Keepsakes

Is a stuffed animal a good gift for an adult?

The short answer

A stuffed animal can be a good gift for an adult. Age is not what decides it: many adults keep theirs for decades, and research on teddy bears found the owner's bond matters most to its comfort. A new one has none yet, so tie it to something you share or they love and choose one good to hold.

Is a stuffed animal too childish to be a good gift for an adult?

Picture the reaction you are afraid of: a polite smile at a child's toy. Adults' own habits say otherwise. More than half of 2,004 Americans who have or had a stuffed animal still owned one, and 56% had held on to their favorite for more than two decades, in a 2017 survey Build-A-Bear commissioned. Grown-ups buy toys for themselves as well: 43% of US adults had done so in the past year, the market research firm Circana found in its May 2024 survey.

One owner of Lucille the Duck, reviewing it on the site of its maker, Blabla Kids, wrote, "I got her for myself and I am 52 years old!" Another, a mother of two teenagers, adds her own to her teenagers' old collection: "Perfect cheer up in dark times."

What a teddy bear can do for a grown-up

In two experiments, an unfamiliar teddy bear changed how people treated others, though only people who had just been made to feel left out. University students in that state held an 80 cm bear for 3 minutes, handed to them as a product to evaluate; others only saw it from a distance. Given $10 to split with another person, left-out students who had held the teddy bear passed on $4.50 on average, against $3.33 for left-out students who had only seen it. The researchers traced the difference to a lift in positive emotion, and people who had not been left out showed no such change. The authors note that the studies ran in one industrialized setting and ask for them to be repeated in other cultures.

People who brought their own teddy bears to a participatory study at the European Researchers' Night put the bond first. The researchers looked at how bears look, smell and feel, and found that

"the emotional bond shared with a teddy bear is a predominant factor."

Among the bears' traits, how they felt to the touch counted especially, and none of it changed with age. That is the catch for a giver: whatever bond a new one has will have to begin with the gift itself.

So the bond starts with you. When people in that same Build-A-Bear survey thought back to a childhood stuffed animal, 30% first remembered a feeling of comfort; next, for 22%, came whoever had given it to them, ahead of what it looked like (19%).

Givers tend to skip the sentimental option. Offered a gift matching someone's known tastes or one tied to the people, events or times in their life, givers picked the first much more often than its recipients would have, because the first felt safe and the second like a gamble.

The ties people choose are specific. One buyer chose Coral & Tusk's Three Little Bears Pocket Pillow for a couple renewing their vows because "the wife really misses Alaska," and its "conifers and bears and log beds" were meant "to remind her of home." Another gave one to a daughter who loves quilts; it is on display in her living room.

Pick it for the feel and the space

Then choose it the way they will live with it. The people receiving a gift weigh how practical it is, while givers weigh how appealing it is, gift research has found. The test is in your hands, then. After the bond, how a bear felt mattered most in the comfort research, so choose one that feels good to hold, at a size that fits where it will sit.

The maker of the Catalina Mouse, Hazel Village, frames the gift around comfort: "Gifting a stuffed animal to an adult may seem silly, but we believe it can be a powerful thing to remind a loved one that they are deserving of comfort."

For a partner, or anyone close

The closer you are to someone, the stronger another pull: toward a gift that proves how well you know them. Givers close to the recipient who knew they would be credited for a gift were more likely to leave a registry for something that signaled the relationship, across five studies, while less close givers stuck to the list more often and so matched what the recipient wanted. A girlfriend or boyfriend is about as close as givers get, so that is the pull to check first. As our piece on gifts as identity claims puts it, "What you choose says as much about your perception as their reality." Ask whether it ties to something of theirs before you ask whether it is cute.

If one feels right for them, find it among the stuffed animals in our selection.

Read next

Baby & Keepsakes

What this rests on

34 claims, from Tribot et al. (2023), The Journal of Positive Psychology 2023, Build-A-Bear Workshop survey (2017, commissioned by Build-A-Bear) 2017, Circana (2024), U.S. toy industry release 2024, Tai, Zheng and Narayanan (2011), Social Psychological and Personality Science 2011, Givi and Galak (2017), Journal of Consumer Psychology 2017, Baskin, Wakslak, Trope and Novemsky (2014), Journal of Consumer Research 2014, Ward and Broniarczyk (2016), Journal of Marketing Research 2016, Review on Blabla Kids' own site of Lucille the Duck, as recorded on our Blabla Kids Lucille the Duck page, Review on Coral & Tusk's own site of the Three Little Bears Pocket Pillow, as recorded on our Coral & Tusk Three Little Bears Pocket Pillow page, Hazel Village's own words, as recorded on our Catalina Mouse page and Every Gift Is an Identity Claim 2026. Each has its own address.

Grouped under the record each claim came from.

Tribot et al. (2023), The Journal of Positive Psychology 2023

Our study revealed that the emotional bond shared with a teddy bear is a predominant factor.

cite

However, we identified characteristics that play a significant role in the perception of comfort, which lies in a combination of visual, olfactory, and especially kinesthetic characteristics.

cite

These results were independent of participants’ age, reminiscent of the teddy bear’s ability to provide comfort at all stages of life.

cite

Through a participatory study conducted during the European Researchers’ Night, this study aims to identify characteristics of teddy bears that influence their comforting power, including visual, olfactory and kinesthetic properties.

cite

We would like to thank all the participants of the European Researchers’ Night and their teddy bears.

cite

Build-A-Bear Workshop survey (2017, commissioned by Build-A-Bear) 2017

56% of respondents have owned (and held onto) their favorite stuffed animal for more than two decades.

cite

30% of respondents said a feeling of comfort was the first memory that came to mind when thinking about a childhood stuffed animal, followed by the memory of the person who gave it to them (22%), and the stuffed animal's appearance (19%).

cite

Across generations, more than half of all respondents surveyed mentioned they still own a stuffed animal.

cite

The Build-A-Bear survey was conducted by Atomik Research on a sample of 2,004 consumers in the United States who have/had a stuffed animal and in accordance with MRA guidelines and regulations. The online survey was fielded between August 1 and 3, 2017.

cite

The survey of 2,000 adults, completed by Atomik Research and commissioned by Build-A-Bear

cite

Circana (2024), U.S. toy industry release 2024

In fact, 43% of adults purchased a toy for themselves in the past year, with the top reasons being for socialization, enjoyment, and collecting

cite

3 Source: Circana, U.S. Omnibus, May 2024

cite

Tai, Zheng and Narayanan (2011), Social Psychological and Personality Science 2011

Across two studies, we found that socially excluded individuals who touched a teddy bear acted more prosocially as compared to socially excluded individuals who just viewed the teddy bear from a distance.

cite

This effect was only observed for socially excluded participants and not for socially included (or control) participants.

cite

In Study 2, positive emotion was found to mediate the relationship between touch and prosocial behavior.

cite

Next, participants were asked to evaluate a consumer product—an 80 cm teddy bear—and rate its appeal on various filler items.

cite

Participants were left alone in the room for 3 min to touch and evaluate the teddy bear.

cite

Participants were 181 undergraduates (115 women and 66 men) who participated for course credit.

cite

Participants were 95 undergraduates (55 women and 40 men) who participated for course credit.

cite

the excluded–touch group (M = $4.50, SD = 1.85) offered more money than the excluded–no touch group (M = $3.33, SD = 1.86)

cite

Participants were endowed with $10 and they could divide it in any way between themselves and the other person.

cite

Our studies were conducted in an industrialized context and this may have inflated some of our effects. Thus, our results need to be replicated in other cultural contexts in order to establish the generalizability of our findings.

cite

Givi and Galak (2017), Journal of Consumer Psychology 2017

that when faced with the choice between sentimentally valuable gifts and gifts with superficial attributes that match the preferences of the recipient, givers give the latter much more often than recipients would prefer to receive such gifts.

cite

Sentimental value is the value derived from an emotionally-laden item’s associations with significant others, or special events or times in one’s life.

cite

This asymmetry appears to be driven by givers feeling relatively certain that preference-matching gifts will be well-liked by recipients, but relatively uncertain that the same is true for sentimentally valuable gifts.

cite

Baskin, Wakslak, Trope and Novemsky (2014), Journal of Consumer Research 2014

unlike receivers, givers construe gifts abstractly and therefore weight desirability attributes more than feasibility attributes.

cite

Ward and Broniarczyk (2016), Journal of Marketing Research 2016

Five studies in a gift registry context show that when close (vs. distant) givers receive attribution for the gifts they choose, they are more likely to diverge from the registry to choose items that signal their close relationships.

cite

Ironically, distant givers are more likely to choose gifts from the registry, resulting in the selection of items that better match recipients’ preferences.

cite

Review on Blabla Kids' own site of Lucille the Duck, as recorded on our Blabla Kids Lucille the Duck page

I love Lucille the Duck! I got her for myself and I am 52 years old! I will be taking her with me to my first grade classroom this fall so she can be our class friend!

cite

Love her! I am mother of two teenagers and all their old bla bla dolls are in loved but good condition. In the meantime I add to the collection with my own. Perfect cheer up in dark times.

cite

Review on Coral & Tusk's own site of the Three Little Bears Pocket Pillow, as recorded on our Coral & Tusk Three Little Bears Pocket Pillow page

This is a gift for the renewal of wedding vows between an American from Alaska and an Australian. They live in Australia and the wife really misses Alaska. So this should be perfect to remind her of home: conifers and bears and log beds. Always high quality, original. Mahalo!

cite

I purchased this lovely and pretty pillow as a birthday gift for my daughter who loves quilts. She was very happy when I handed it to her! She has the pillow on display in her living room. Thank you.

cite

Hazel Village's own words, as recorded on our Catalina Mouse page

Gifting a stuffed animal to an adult may seem silly, but we believe it can be a powerful thing to remind a loved one that they are deserving of comfort.

cite

Every Gift Is an Identity Claim 2026

The gift reveals both parties. What you choose says as much about your perception as their reality.

cite