Is perfume a good gift?
Perfume is a good gift when the scent is the person's own choice: the bottle they already wear, or one they've mentioned wanting. The risk isn't that perfume is too personal. It's buying a new scent because it seems like them, a pick that research on other gifts finds givers lean toward, and people rarely say when a gift missed.
Say you have found a scent that seems exactly like them, one you are sure would make a good gift, and the bottle already on their shelf feels like the lazy choice. Any gift is your guess at who someone is, and a beautiful one that guesses wrong still misses. With perfume, the guess is one they would wear on their own skin. And the guess tends to lean one way: Mary Steffel, Elanor Williams and Robyn LeBoeuf found that givers favour gifts suited to a person's traits and personality over the varied things that person actually wants.
The study that swapped a man's own perfume for another
One experiment looked at what happens when the perfume on someone's skin is not their own pick, and it was not about gifts at all. In a 2012 study, Pavlina Lenochova and colleagues recruited 12 men who each wore a perfume he had picked himself, "not a gift bought by someone else," as the researchers put it. Each man wore his own perfume under one arm and, under the other, the same perfume the researchers assigned to everyone.
- Sniffed on their own, the two perfumes were rated no different in how pleasant they were, though the assigned one came across stronger.
- Worn, each man's own choice was rated more attractive and more pleasant, with no difference in strength.
The authors add an aside, not a finding: perfume shoppers often complain that perfumes given to them do not really suit them, and that they have to try a scent on their own skin.
It is a small study, and the authors say their results are restricted to male wearers.
Who the perfume is for matters too. Mostly with gift cards, givers in the Steffel experiments dwelt on someone's character and underweighted what that person needs right now. The tilt grew when the recipient was a romantic partner rather than a friend; the people on the receiving end wanted the same thing either way. Their work drew partly on industry data.
When perfume is a good gift: the scent they already chose
So the bottle they already wear is not the lazy gift. They chose it themselves, which is exactly what that study put to the test. A scent they have mentioned wanting counts too: in a separate study by Morgan Ward and Susan Broniarczyk, people were clearly happier with a close friend's gift when it was the item they had asked for than when the friend chose something else. That study used lamps, and its authors leave other products to future research. Either way, what someone uses tells you more than what they thank you for, and a perfume they put on every day has already given you its answer.
A thank-you won't reveal a miss. People rarely say how they really feel about a gift they dislike, Ward and Broniarczyk note, because thanks are expected for whatever arrives. If you do not know their scent, some scents are not worn at all. One husband gave his wife a Santa Maria Novella Melograno soap, and wrote in his review: "She really enjoys the quality and fragrance which is pleasantly floral and powdery." That is his account of her reaction, which is the only kind of report a giver usually gets.
If a bottle feels like too close a guess at their taste, the candles and incense we chose carry scent into a room instead.
Read next
What this rests on
15 claims, from Lenochova et al., PLoS ONE (materials donated by industry) 2012, Steffel, Williams and LeBoeuf, Advances in Consumer Research (industry-supported) 2015, Ward and Broniarczyk, Journal of Marketing Research 2016, Customer review, Smallflower, as recorded on our Santa Maria Novella Melograno Soap page and Every Gift Is an Identity Claim 2026. Each has its own address.
Grouped under the record each claim came from.
Lenochova et al., PLoS ONE (materials donated by industry) 2012
All participants used a perfume that they had personally chosen (not a gift bought by someone else) and which they found pleasant.
citeThe odor blends with the participants' own perfume were rated significantly more attractive (Z = 2.37; N = 21; p = 0.02) and pleasant (Z = 2.48; N = 21; p = 0.01) than blends with the assigned perfume, but there was no significant difference in intensity.
citeThe results of the current study are restricted to the effect of perfume usage in male wearers.
citeAnecdotally, there are common complaints among perfumery customers that perfumes given to them do not really suit them and that, when choosing a perfume, they must try it on their own skin.
citeThe authors are also very grateful for a material donation provided by the Yves Rocher, Optimum Distribution CZ & SK and Fann Parfumery. The funders had no role in study design, data collection and analysis, decision to publish, or preparation of the manuscript. Competing interests: Yves Rocher, Optimum distribution CZ & SK and Fann Parfumery provided a material donation to this study.
citeSteffel, Williams and LeBoeuf, Advances in Consumer Research (industry-supported) 2015
This research shows that givers favor gifts that are specifically appropriate for the recipient but are less versatile than what the recipient would prefer to receive, largely because givers tend to focus on recipients’ unique traits and personalities rather than on their multiple, varying wants and needs.
citeGivers preferred giving a tailored store gift card over a Visa gift card to a greater extent for a romantic partner than a friend (t(197) = 4.01, p < .001, d = .57), but recipients’ preferences between the gift cards did not vary based on their relationship to the giver (t(180.31) = .74, p = .46, d = .11).
citegivers rated themselves more likely to consider what their friend was like as a person when choosing a gift than recipients were to consider what they were like as a person when suggesting gifts they would want to receive (t(169) = 5.58, p < .001, d = .84). And, givers were less likely than recipients to consider the recipient’s current wants and needs when choosing gifts
citeWard and Broniarczyk, Journal of Marketing Research 2016
Specifically, recipients were significantly happier with their close friends’ gifts when the giver chose the registry item (M = 9.25) than when they selected a non-registry gift (M = 6.36, F (1, 42) = 12.8, p < .001)
citerecipients rarely give diagnostic feedback about the true nature of their feelings about a disliked gift
citeCustomer review, Smallflower, as recorded on our Santa Maria Novella Melograno Soap page
I purchased this soap for my wife recently. She really enjoys the quality and fragrance which is pleasantly floral and powdery. The soap makes a wonderful package presentation and gift!
citeEvery Gift Is an Identity Claim 2026
The gift becomes your hypothesis about who they are.
citeA beautiful object that misidentifies the recipient fails even if the craftsmanship is impeccable.
citepay attention to what they use, not what they thank you for. The gift that stays in the drawer told you something. The gift they wear every day told you more.
citeGivers rarely learn when they've gotten the identity claim wrong because recipients perform appreciation regardless.
cite