What gift do you give a friend you haven’t seen in years?
For a friend you haven't seen in years, give something from a good time you shared, like a photo of the two of you, not a guess at what they like now. In a study of gifts between friends, the people receiving wanted a photo of the two of them more often than givers chose it.
It tends to feel the other way round while you're choosing: a gift picked for who they are now looks like the careful option, and a memory looks like a gamble. After years apart, though, the careful-looking gift is the guess.
Is a memory too risky a gift for a friend you haven't seen in years?
In a 2017 study, researchers Julian Givi and Jeff Galak asked people to name a friend and choose between two gifts of equal price: a 20-by-30-inch, high-quality framed photo of the friend's favorite musician, or a framed 8-by-10 of the two of them, somewhat low in quality, from a day they had a lot of fun together. Everyone took part online, picturing the choice rather than making it.
For a birthday, 63.2% of givers chose the photo of the two of them, while 78.8% of people picturing themselves on the receiving end wanted it. And for a going-away gift, 95.5% of those on the receiving end wanted the smaller, lower-quality photo of the two of them, against 75.9% of givers who chose it.
Why would givers hold back from the gift people wanted? The gap seems to come down to certainty: givers feel surer that a gift matched to someone's tastes will be liked than a sentimental one, so they give the sentimental one less often than the people receiving would like.
A matched gift, in the researchers' own definition, has features the recipient is "known to like". After years apart, that knowledge is the part you're missing. Nothing in the study singled out friends who had lost touch, so applying it to yours is our reading.
If you've drifted apart
Givers and the people on the receiving end both picked the photo of the two of them more often when the two friends were closer. A friend you've drifted from may want it less than a close friend would. Close or not, givers still chose it less often than those on the receiving end wanted it.
Will it feel awkward after so long?
The other worry is turning up with anything at all after so long. In one version of that, college students in a 2022 experiment by Peggy Liu and colleagues sent a note and a voucher for a bag of candy and snacks to a classmate they hadn't been in touch with for a while. On a scale from 1 (not at all) to 5 (extremely), the senders guessed their classmate's appreciation at 4.25; the classmates reported 4.72.
In the paper's other experiments, the gap disappeared when the contact was expected and grew between people who weren't close — so the more out of the blue your gesture and the further you've drifted, the more likely you are to underrate how it lands.
What kind of memory, and how big
So keep it small, and make it a good memory.
- Small, because a note and a small gift is what Liu's team tested, and a gesture too big for the relationship, such as an expensive bouquet for someone you don't know well, is on their list of untested cases.
- A good memory, because sentimental value, in Givi and Galak's definition, comes from good associations, not from someone you've come to dislike or a time that went badly.
- A friendship that ended in a falling-out sits outside both papers, and there senders may even overestimate the welcome, a possibility raised but never tested.
And if the two of you never shared much of a past to draw on, a memory can't carry the gift; that's the moment for a gift that shows your own taste instead.
Read next
Closer Bonds Through Self-Disclosure. Why Sharing Your Taste Works
What this rests on
24 claims, from Sentimental value and gift giving: Givers' fears of getting it wrong prevents them from getting it right 2017, The Surprise of Reaching Out: Appreciated More Than We Think 2022 and Closer Bonds Through Self-Disclosure. Why Sharing Your Taste Works 2026. Each has its own address.
Grouped under the record each claim came from.
The present research demonstrates that when faced with the choice between sentimentally valuable gifts and gifts with superficial attributes that match the preferences of the recipient, givers give the latter much more often than recipients would prefer to receive such gifts.
citeThis asymmetry appears to be driven by givers feeling relatively certain that preference-matching gifts will be well-liked by recipients, but relatively uncertain that the same is true for sentimentally valuable gifts.
citeUnder these circumstances, givers will likely feel relatively certain that a preference-matching gift (which, by definition, possesses superficial attributes the recipient is known to like), will be well-liked by the recipient.
citeAs predicted, when deciding on a birthday gift, givers were less likely to give the sentimentally valuable gift (63.2% (60/97), than recipients were to prefer to receive it (78.8% (67/85); χ2 (1, N = 180) = 5.30, p = .021, φ = .17).
citeSimilarly, when deciding on a going away gift, givers were less likely to give the sentimentally valuable gift (75.9% (63/83), than recipients were to prefer to receive it (95.5% (64/67); χ2 (1, N = 150) = 10.00, p = .001, φ = .27).
citeFurther, the associations must be with positive aspects of one’s life (i.e., not associations with a now-disliked person, or an unpleasant event or time; Yang & Galak, 2015).
citeIn sum, Study 1’s results provide initial evidence that givers do not give sentimentally valuable gifts as often as recipients would prefer, and demonstrate this effect is not attenuated by the occasion or social closeness.
citeConsistent with our prediction, givers were less likely to give the sentimentally valuable gift (23.6% (33/140), than recipients were to prefer to receive it (34.3% (48/140); β = .79, z = 2.32, p = .021).
citeAll participants began the study by writing the name of a friend.
citeThese results suggest givers give sentimentally valuable gifts more often to closer (vs. more distant) friends, but still not nearly as often as these close friends would like, and that this does not vary based on the occasion.
citeFour hundred and two Amazon Mechanical Turk workers (237 females (59%); Mage = 35.90, SD = 11.51) completed the study in exchange for $0.20.
cite1) A framed, 20-inch by 30-inch, high-quality photograph of the friend’s favorite musician (the preference-matching gift); or 2) Developing (in size 8-inch by 10-inch) and framing a somewhat low-quality photograph of them and their friend on a day they had a lot of fun together (that was stored on their computer), and giving it as a gift (the sentimentally valuable gift).
citegivers and recipients are also aligned in their beliefs about the importance of social closeness on giving a sentimentally valuable gift, as a logistic regression on choice of the sentimentally valuable gift with only the social closeness measure entered as a predictor reveals that the sentimentally valuable gift was chosen more often when the friend was socially closer (β = .41, p = .001)
citeThe Surprise of Reaching Out: Appreciated More Than We Think 2022
Across a series of preregistered experiments, we document a robust underestimation of how much other people appreciate being reached out to.
citeInitiators (M = 4.25, SD = .86) significantly underestimated how much their reach-outs were appreciated compared to how much responders (M = 4.72, SD = .62) appreciated them, Mdifference = −.46, 95% CI [−.66, −.26], t(66) = −4.60, p < .001, dz = .56.
citeIn particular, Experiment 6 found that the underestimation of reach-out appreciation occurred when the reach-out was in a context that was surprising to the responder, whereas it was eliminated when the reach-out was in a context that was not surprising to the responder.
citeExperiment 7 shows that the underestimation of reach-out appreciation occurs both within strong and weak tie relationships but is even stronger within weak tie relationships.
citeExperiment 3 is another field experiment on a college campus, also involving actual reach-out experiences conducted with dyads, wherein people wrote notes and sent small gifts to college classmates with whom they had not had contact in some time.
citeOn the same page, initiators were informed that the responder would receive a survey link that allows them to read their note, receive a gift voucher redeemable for a bag of assorted candy/snacks, and answer a question about how they feel.
citeFinally, participants predicted the extent to which the responder would appreciate that they chose them to reach out with their note and gift voucher (1 = not at all,2 = slightly,3 = moderately,4 = very,5 = extremely).
citeRelatedly, future research might expand to examine reach-outs in the context of prior negative interactions and how they may differ from reaching out within mostly positive interaction relationships.
citeOne possibility is that responders may feel more negative feelings of surprise, which initiators might be less focused on as they predict responder appreciation, such that initiators might even overestimate appreciation.
citeHowever, future work might examine whether the underestimation of reach-out appreciation differs for reach-outs that carry with them more neutral or even slightly negative feelings of surprise, such as reach-outs that are inappropriate for the relationship
citeCloser Bonds Through Self-Disclosure. Why Sharing Your Taste Works 2026
Choosing something you love, rather than something you think they'll love, is an act of revelation.
cite